What Are You Asking People to Lose?

Markus Spiske from Unsplash
Have you ever held on to something longer than you should have because you didn’t want to let it go?
Perhaps it was a project you’d spent months developing, a role you’d outgrown, an item you no longer needed or a decision you were reluctant to revisit. You can become attached to what you already have, even when letting go could leave you better off.
Psychologist Daniel Kahneman and behavioural economists Jack Knetsch and Richard Thaler demonstrated this tendency in a series of experiments involving coffee mugs.¹ In one experiment, some participants were given a mug and asked how much they’d accept to sell it. Others were asked how much they’d pay to buy one.
The results were revealing. Those who owned a mug wanted roughly twice as much to part with it as others were prepared to pay. It turned out that simply owning something had changed how much people valued it.
The researchers suggested that one explanation for this difference is loss aversion: our tendency to weigh what we stand to lose more heavily than what we might gain.
Once you own something, giving it up can feel like a greater loss than the benefit someone else sees in acquiring it. The prospect of loss can also motivate you to act, particularly when the consequences are immediate.
If you’re seeking to influence others, understanding how people respond to potential loss can help you recognise what encourages action and what holds people back.
Build the emotional intelligence and negotiation skills to understand others →
What My Pilates Bookings Taught Me
You see this tendency play out in all sorts of everyday situations, including, for me, my Pilates classes.
Now, I enjoy Pilates, but there are certainly times when I’d much rather stay home. Perhaps it’s an early start, the weather is miserable or I simply don’t feel like going. Yet I’ve noticed that I rarely, if ever, cancel a class.
And I realised fairly quickly why. If I cancel within 24 hours, I lose the class I’ve already paid for and get charged a cancellation fee on top.
The thought of losing money I’ve already spent, and then having to pay even more, is a strong motivator to get me out the door.
In my case, the prospect of losing something helps me stick to a commitment I’ve made. However, that same reluctance to lose something can also make it harder to move forward when circumstances change.
When the Fear of Losing Holds Us Back
Imagine you’re being asked to give up responsibility for an area you’ve managed for years. The proposed change might make sense for your organisation, but for you, it could mean losing autonomy, influence or a sense of professional identity.
Even when you recognise the benefits of a change, what you’re being asked to give up can weigh heavily on your willingness to support it, particularly when it impacts something you value.
Transition expert William Bridges argued that organisational transitions begin with endings.²
When you’re going through change, you need time to come to terms with what you’re being asked to leave behind. Yet when you’re leading change, it’s easy to focus more of your effort on ‘selling’ the future benefits and overlook what others feel they’re losing.
When Loss Becomes a Motivator
So, how can you use your understanding of loss to encourage action? One approach is to consider how you present a decision or opportunity.
Behavioural economists Tanjim Hossain and John List examined this in a study involving productivity bonuses at a manufacturing facility in China.³
Some workers were offered bonuses for meeting productivity targets, while others were told they would lose a provisional bonus if they didn’t meet them. Both approaches increased productivity, but the loss framing had a stronger effect on teams. It increased team productivity compared with the gain framing, and the effect held throughout the study.
These findings suggest that people may respond more strongly when an incentive is framed as something they could lose.
So, if highlighting potential losses can encourage action, should you use that approach more often?
Is Emphasising Loss Always Effective?
It’s tempting to assume that because people can respond strongly to potential losses, highlighting them will help you influence others.
However, in a theoretical review, psychologists David Gal and Derek Rucker argue that the evidence doesn’t support loss aversion as a general principle.4 They contend that many effects attributed to loss aversion may actually reflect other factors, such as inertia or the way choices are structured.
The practical implication is that the impact of loss-based messages likely depends on context. Consequently, be careful about when and how you emphasise potential losses. For example, consider who you’re trying to influence, their circumstances, and what they value before deciding how to frame your message.
Find Out How Your Beliefs Are Making Decisions For You →
Five Ways to Work With Loss
1. Recognise What You’re Afraid of Losing
Before asking others to change, consider how the prospect of loss might be influencing your decisions.
Perhaps you’re reluctant to delegate because you value the control you have, or you’re holding on to responsibilities that have become part of your professional identity.
Recognising what you fear losing can help you examine whether those concerns are influencing your judgement more than they should.
Ask yourself:
- What am I concerned about losing if I make this change?
- How much is that concern influencing my decision about what to do next?
2. Acknowledge What People Are Giving Up
When you’re leading change, take time to understand what impacted people believe they’ll lose. It might be autonomy, valued relationships or the confidence that comes from knowing how things work.
These concerns can be easy to overlook when you’re convinced the proposed change will deliver better outcomes.
Start by asking people what they value about the current arrangements and what concerns them about moving forward. As you move through these conversations, you’ll likely discover things worth preserving, along with issues that need more attention.
Consider:
- What might people feel they’re losing through this change that I haven’t fully appreciated?
- What could I preserve or address to help them move forward?
3. Make the Cost of Standing Still Visible
When you’re proposing change, it’s natural to examine the risks of proceeding. However, the consequences of doing nothing can receive less attention.
Consider what delaying a decision could mean for customers, your team members and colleagues, capability, costs, profitability or competitive position.
Where possible, quantify those consequences, including how they could increase over time. At the same time, be equally rigorous in assessing the risks of moving forward. That way, you’ll have a more complete picture of what’s at stake, the upside and downside of the opportunity and a stronger basis for explaining why action may be needed.
Ask yourself:
- What could we lose if we continue with the current approach?
- What evidence, experience and expertise can I apply to make the consequences of acting and waiting more visible?
4. Frame Your Message Around What Matters to Them
Once you understand what’s at stake, consider how best to communicate it to the people you’re trying to influence.
What matters to them will shape how they interpret your proposal. For example, someone concerned about losing autonomy may want to understand how they’ll retain a voice in future decisions. Someone concerned about losing status may want to understand how the change will affect their decision-making authority.
Use what you’ve learned to explain the opportunities and potential losses in ways that are relevant to their concerns. Keep your message balanced and grounded in the reality of the context you are operating in.
Consider:
- What matters most to the person I’m seeking to influence, and how might that shape their response?
- Am I presenting the potential gains and losses fairly, or emphasising one at the expense of the other?
5. Help People Make Commitments They’ll Keep
Gaining agreement is one step. Helping people follow through on what they’ve agreed to is another.
My Pilates bookings remind me that immediate consequences can encourage me to honour a commitment I’ve already made.
You can apply a similar principle at work by helping your team and colleagues establish specific actions, deadlines and ways to hold themselves accountable. That might involve agreeing to share progress with a colleague, scheduling a review or identifying a milestone they want to achieve.
Where possible, let people choose how they’ll demonstrate their commitment. The aim is to make follow-through easier while giving them ownership of the process.
Ask yourself:
- What specific commitment would help turn agreement into action?
- How can I help people establish accountability that they’ll willingly accept and follow through on?
Your Next Step
Think about where you are trying to influence. It might be one change you’re currently leading or one decision you’ve been putting off
Write down what could be lost by moving forward and what could be lost by staying where things are. Then consider whose perspective is missing from your assessment.
If you’re leading others, use those insights to have a more informed conversation about the change. You’ll be better placed to understand what’s driving hesitation and where people need support.
Republished with courtesy from michellegibbings.com.
Leadership
Tags: Empathy, Team Leadership
References:
- Kahneman, D., Knetsch, J. L., and Thaler, R. H. (1990). Experimental tests of the endowment effect and the Coase theorem. Journal of Political Economy, 98(6), 1325–1348. https://doi.org/10.1086/261737
- Bridges, W., and Bridges, S. (2017). Managing transitions: Making the most of change (4th ed.). Da Capo Lifelong Books.
- Hossain, T., and List, J. A. (2012). The behavioralist visits the factory: Increasing productivity using simple framing manipulations. Management Science, 58(12), 2151–2167. https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.1120.1544
- Gal, D., and Rucker, D. D. (2018). The loss of loss aversion: Will it loom larger than its gain? Journal of Consumer Psychology, 28(3), 497–516. https://doi.org/10.1002/jcpy.1047
Michelle Gibbings is a workplace expert and the award-winning author of three books. Her latest book is 'Bad Boss: What to do if you work for one, manage one or are one'. www.michellegibbings.com.





