How HR Handles Leave Conflict During Festive Seasons
Freepik
The festive season brings warmth, celebration, and, inevitably, the peak tension between employee desires and operational needs. When half the team wants December 24th off and the business still needs to run, Leave Conflict escalates from an administrative headache to a significant morale issue.
HR’s role here is to act as the impartial, transparent architect of a system that employees trust, ensuring fairness and respect for the diversity of celebrations.
Related: 5 Mistakes Managers Make That Sabotage Performance Reviews
1. Establish Clear Deadlines
Conflict thrives in ambiguity. The single most effective way to reduce holiday leave tension is to move the decision-making process out of the pressure cooker of November and December.
- The Mistake: Announcing the deadline late or allowing managers to informally hold requests without submitting them through the system.
- The HR Fix: The 'First-Come, Fair-Served' Cutoff.
HR must communicate a strict, mandatory submission deadline for all core festive season leave (e.g., September 30th). Beyond this date, approval is only granted if core business staffing requirements are already met. This system rewards forward planning and removes the guilt from managers who have to say no later on.
2. Implement a Prioritized System (The Tiers of Fairness)
When multiple high-priority requests come in simultaneously, a first-come, first-served rule can feel arbitrary and unfair, especially to employees with less flexible roles or those who just missed the memo. HR must design a system that introduces intentional, visible fairness.
| Priority Tier | Rule / Criteria | Cultural Impact |
| Tier 1: Carry-Over / Non-Negotiable | Employees who were denied leave the previous festive season automatically get priority this year for the same dates. | Rewards loyalty and ensures equity over a two-year cycle. |
| Tier 2: Critical Cultural Dates | Accommodation for specific, non-floating religious/cultural days that are not recognized public holidays (e.g., specific days of Diwali, Eid, or Orthodox Christmas). | Honors diversity and demonstrates respect for employee faith/culture. |
| Tier 3: Seniority/Tenure | If all else is equal, longer-serving employees receive marginal preference. | Acknowledges commitment and is a clear, objective tie-breaker. |
| Tier 4: Rotating Coverage | Teams must rotate coverage of peak dates (e.g., half the team works Christmas Eve this year, the other half works it next year). | Prevents burnout and ensures no single employee is always stuck covering the holidays. |
HR's Role: Ensure managers strictly adhere to this objective hierarchy. The system, not the manager's personal preference, makes the decision.
Budaya (powered by Happily.ai) help HR surface early signs of tension through real-time pulse checks and sentiment insights. Explore Budaya today.
3. Focus on Coverage
Too often, managers equate having a body in a chair with having sufficient coverage. HR needs to shift the focus from who is present to what needs to be accomplished.
- The Mistake: Managers deny leave because they feel they need everyone, without specifically defining the minimum skill coverage required.
- The HR Fix: Skill-based minimums. Work with departments to define the minimum operational skill set required to sustain core functions during the festive period (e.g., one person certified in system A, two people who can handle critical client B, etc.). Leave is then approved up to the point that these skill minimums are met. This maximizes flexibility while minimizing operational risk.
4. Offer Strategic Non-Monetary Incentives
Sometimes, a genuine business need requires someone to sacrifice their preferred time off. When this happens, mere thanks are not enough. HR must provide incentives that acknowledge the personal cost.
- The Fix: The Festive Duty Exchange
If an employee agrees to cancel or postpone their requested leave to cover a critical festive shift, offer high-value, non-monetary trade-offs:- Flex-Year Priority: Grant them Tier 1 leave priority for the next five consecutive holidays.
- Extra Time Off: Offer an additional two paid floating days to be used in the less-busy shoulder seasons (e.g., February or May).
- Compensatory Flexibility: Grant Work From Home status for the entire week surrounding the covered holiday, regardless of normal policy.
5. Communicate the Final Decision with Empathy and Context
The delivery of a "no" is where trust is either built or shattered.
- The Delivery: When a manager has to deny a request, the communication from HR (or the manager, trained by HR) must be swift, regretful, and accompanied by the reason, citing the objective system and operational need.
- Example: "We sincerely regret that we cannot approve your December 24th request. As you know, Jane, our policy prioritizes those who covered last year (Tier 1). However, we are happy to approve December 27th-31st and have granted you Tier 1 priority for the 2026 season."
By creating a transparent, objective, and empathetic framework, HR transforms the festive leave period from a yearly source of conflict into an exercise in organisational fairness and respect for cultural needs.
Leadership
Tags: HR
Marissa Lau is an organisational development practitioner with a background in psychological science. She is the Head of Budaya, a culture and engagement department that helps organisations listen better, build healthier workplaces, and turn employee insights into meaningful action. Working at the intersection of leadership, culture, and human behaviour, Marissa translates complex ideas into practical insights for individuals and organisations, while bringing experience in project coordination and cross-functional delivery. Her work focuses on employee engagement, workplace wellbeing, learning innovation, and the future of work, with a strong belief in building human-centred organisations where both people and performance can thrive.
