“Marking a book is literally an experience of your differences or agreements with the author. It is the highest respect you can pay him.” – Edgar Allen Poe
You already know how to read. I bet you were taught how in elementary school. But do you know how to read well?
If you’re like most people, you probably haven’t given much thought to how you read.
Are you reading for information or understanding?
While great for exercising your memory, the regurgitation of facts without understanding gains you nothing.
A lot of people, however, confuse insightful understanding with the ability to regurgitate information. They think that knowledge of something means understanding.
A good heuristic: Anything easily digested is reading for information.
Consider the newspaper, are you truly learning anything new? Do you consider the writer your superior when it comes to knowledge in the subject?
Odds are probably not. That means you’re reading for information. There’s nothing wrong with that; it’s how most people read.
But you’re not really learning anything new. It’s not going to give you an edge or make you better at your job.
Learning something insightful is harder, you have to read something clearly above your current level. You need to find writers who are more knowledgeable on a particular subject than yourself. It’s also how you get smarter.
Reading for understanding means narrowing the gap between reader and writer.
The four levels of reading
Mortimer Adler literally wrote a book on reading.
His book, How to Read a Book, identifies four levels of reading:
The goal of reading determines how you read.
Reading the latest Danielle Steel novel is not the same as reading Plato.
If you’re reading for entertainment or information, you’re going to read a lot differently (and likely different material) than reading to increase understanding.
While many people are proficient in reading for information and entertainment, few improve their ability to read for knowledge.
Before we can improve our reading skills, we need to understand the differences in the reading levels.
They are thought of as levels because you can’t move to a higher level without a firm understanding of the previous one — they are cumulative.
1. Elementary reading
This is the level of reading taught in our elementary schools.
2. Inspectional reading
We’ve been taught that skimming and superficial reading are bad for understanding. That is not necessarily the case.
Using these tools effectively can increase understanding. Inspectional reading allows us to look at the author’s blueprint and evaluate the merits of a deeper reading experience.
There are two types of inspectional reading:
- Systematic skimmingThis is meant to be a quick check of the book by:
- reading the preface
- studying the table of contents
- checking the index
- reading the inside jacket
This should give you sufficient knowledge to understand the chapters in the book pivotal to the author’s argument.
Dip in here and there, but never with more than a paragraph or two.
Skimming helps you reach a decision point: Does this book deserve more of my time and attention?
If not, you put it down.
- Superficial readingThis is when you just read. Don’t ponder the argument, don’t look things up, don’t write in the margins. If you don’t understand something, move on.
What you gain from this quick read will help you later when you go back and put more effort into reading.
You now come to another decision point. Now that you have a better understanding of the book contents and its structure, do you want to understand it?
Inspectional reading gives you the gist of things. Sometimes that’s all we want or need. Too often, however, people stop here.
3. Analytical reading
Francis Bacon once remarked:
“Some books are to be tasted, others to be swallowed, and some few to be chewed and digested.”
Think of analytical reading as chewing and digesting. Analytical reading is a thorough reading.
If inspectional reading is the best you can do quickly, this is the best reading you can do given unlimited time.
At this point, you start to engage your mind and dig into the work required to understand what’s being said.
There are rules to analytical reading:
- Classify the book according to kind and subject matter.
- State what the whole book is about with the utmost brevity.
- Enumerate its major parts in their order and relation, and outline these parts as you have outlined the whole.
- Define the problem or problems the author is trying to solve.
You’ll probably notice that while those sound pretty easy, they involve a lot of work.
Fortunately, the inspectional reading you’ve already done has primed you for this. When you’ve done this, you will understand the book but you might not understand the broader subject.
To do that you need to use comparative reading to synthesise knowledge from several books on the same subject.
4. Syntopical reading
This is also known as comparative reading and it represents the most demanding and difficult reading of all.
Syntopical reading involves reading many books on the same subject and comparing and contrasting the ideas.
This task is undertaken by identifying relevant passages, translating the terminology, framing and ordering questions we need answered, defining the issues and having a conversation with the responses.
The goal is not to achieve an overall understanding of any particular book, but rather to determine how to make the books useful to you.
This is all about you and filling in your gaps.
These are the five steps to syntopical reading:
- Finding the relevant passages
You need to find the right books and then the passages that are most relevant to filling your needs.
So, the first step is an inspectional reading of all the works that you have identified as relevant.
- Bringing the author to terms
In analytical reading you must identify the keywords and how they are used by the author. This is fairly straightforward.
The process becomes more complicated now as each author has probably used different terms and concepts to frame their argument.
Now the onus is on you to establish the terms. Rather than using the author’s language, you must use your own.
In short, this is an exercise in translation and synthesis.
- Getting the questions clear
Rather than focus on the problems the author is trying to solve, you need to focus on the questions you want answered.
Just as we must establish our own terminology, so too must we establish our own propositions by shedding light on our problems to which the authors provide answers.
It’s important to frame the questions in such a way that all or most of the authors can be interpreted as providing answers.
Sometimes we might not get an answer to our questions because they might not have been seen as questions by the authors.
- Defining the issues
If you’ve asked a clear question to which there is multiple answers then an issue has been defined.
Opposing answers, now translated into your terms, must be ordered in relation to one another. Understanding multiple perspectives within an issue helps you form an intelligent opinion.
- Analysing the discussion
It’s presumptuous to expect we’ll find a single unchallenged truth to any of our questions.
Our answer is the conflict of opposing answers.
The value is within the discussion you have with these authors. You can now have an informed opinion.
Become a demanding reader
Reading is all about asking the right questions in the right order and seeking answers.
There are four main questions you need to ask of every book:
- What is this book about?
- What is being said in detail and how?
- Is this book true in whole or in part?
- What of it?
If all of this sounds like hard work, you’re right. Most people won’t do it.
But, that’s what sets you apart.